Goblins and IP

One of the most interesting passages in the new HP is on page 517 regarding Goblins’ views on property. I may be reaching a bit, but the first thing I thought of was intellectual property law. According to the passage, Goblins consider the maker rather than the purchaser of an object to be its true owner. Indeed, the purchaser is seen as merely renting the property. This sentence seemed particularly apt: “They [Goblins] consider our habit of keeping goblin-made objects, passing them from wizard-to-wizard without further payment, little more than theft.” That strikes me as the approach taken by the RIAA and MPAA toward copyrights and is fairly close to the Randian conception of IP as well.

So, am I grasping at straws here?

Evidently not. A quick google search for “goblin” and “copyright” turns up this post. Any others?

I promise to move on from Potterblogging soon, but there are several interesting passages, like the one above, that I think at least deserve mention, if not commentary.

One Response to “Goblins and IP”  

  1. 1 Jim Harper

    This is my favorite blog!

Leave a Reply